Text as Data
Regular Section S11
EISA Pan-European Conference on International Relations (PEC), Université Catholique de Lille, 27-31 August 2024.
Section chairs:
Andrew W. Neal, University of Edinburgh
Anselm Vogler, Universität Hamburg
Text as Data
Texts and documents have long served as foundational elements in social scientific research, and recent advancements in methods, approaches, and the accessibility of diverse textual materials offer new research horizons. This section calls for the exploration of text and documents produced by states, government departments, and non-state actors within the spaces, styles, and struggles of international politics. It aims to foster dialogue between IR sub-fields, encouraging researchers to explore innovative avenues for understanding international politics through advanced text and document analysis, including computational text analysis. By integrating diverse perspectives and methodologies, we strive to contribute to the evolving landscape of knowledge in this dynamic field.
The section invites innovative contributions on:
- Understanding how texts and documents are produced and function within and between the spaces of international politics.
- Leveraging computational text analysis, AI, and machine learning, including natural language processing, in the analysis and production of textual materials related to international politics.
- Investigating policy documents – such as national strategies, white papers, risk registers, cyber strategies, treaties, and diplomatic communiqués – in isolation, in context, as practices, and as political phenomena.
- Exploring the impact and significance of text and documents in shaping international policies.
- Scrutinizing the role of document classification, declassification, and archival practices, encompassing state and non-state actors.
Hypothetical example panels:
1. The politics of narrating the polycrisis
The international order is undergoing two fundamental changes at once. It is, on the one hand, confronted with the emergence of new planetary-scale dangers such as global environmental change – epitomizing the advent of what Nathan Alexander Sears referred to as the “age of existential threats.” On the other hand, a series of old threats prevails in the form of interstate wars, hybrid conflicts, and coups. To what extent do official and semi-official documents account for these two simultaneous bundles of crises? And to what conclusions do they negotiate between them? This panel will bring together scholars studying documents that comment on these challenges.
2. Inscribing change into international order
New powers are rising, shifting to forms of multi-alignment, regrouping in new international organizations and decisively working towards altering the international order. While feared by some as a risk to the rule-based international order, favoring revisionist, autocratic agenda, others see promise in the changes towards an international order that is decentered from the Global Northwest, rebalances power and empowers the Global South. How is this changing order of the international, and the entailed struggles, taking place in documents of international politics and international security? And how can these documents be studied? The panel brings together contributions that draw on cutting-edge methodologies and study the emergent redefinition of the international through documents.
3. Global narratives and inter-national specificities
A plethora of international actors continuously (re-)position themselves towards contemporary developments through a vast array of publications, press releases, special reports and other textual data. Through these statements they frame trends, inscribe roles, and narrate trajectories of the international. When reading across such documents, one often encounters a surprising degree of similarities that can either be dismissed as technocratic exercises or appreciated as concerns shared internationally. How do the increasing international tensions affect these commonplaces? How are topics with a high degree of internationally shared concerns such as terrorism, weapons of mass destruction proliferation, or climate change reframed? What struggles manifest in these contestations? This panel brings together scholars that analyze documents to study the changing and, possibly, diverging approaches to transnational issues.